Under-eye creasing is the most common makeup complaint over 50 and the most commonly misdiagnosed. People change concealer three or four times in a year while continuing to do the thing that causes it, which is usually using two or three times as much product as the area can carry.
The reason that area is so unforgiving is anatomical. The skin under the eye is roughly a third the thickness of the skin on your cheek, it holds less moisture, and it sits directly on the orbicularis muscle, which contracts every time you blink — several thousand times a day. The area is also slightly concave, so anything that moves has a low point to move into.
Four things cause creasing, in this order of frequency. Too much product, by a wide margin. An under-hydrated under-eye, which creases more sharply and drinks the concealer dry. A formula that sets rigid, which cracks along the fold. And too much setting powder — which is the standard fix and is itself the fourth cause.
Work through them in that order. The great majority of people stop needing a new concealer somewhere around step three, and the steps are free.
The nasolabial fold creases for a related but distinct reason, and the method there is different — see how to stop makeup creasing in smile lines and best concealer for smile lines.
The cheapest reduction in how much concealer ends up under your eyes is the application order, which is covered on concealer before or after foundation.