Creasing is the single most common complaint about makeup on mature skin, and the thing worth knowing before you buy anything is that it has four causes, three of which are free to fix. People change concealer four times in a year while continuing to do the three things that were actually causing it.
Cause one: too much product. This is the biggest by a distance. A crease is a fold in the skin, and a fold collects whatever is loose nearby. The more product sitting on the surface, the more there is to collect. Most people use two or three times what they need.
Cause two: an under-hydrated under-eye. Thin skin that is short of water creases more readily and the creases are sharper. It also drinks moisture out of the concealer, which then dries, stiffens and breaks along the fold.
Cause three: a formula that sets rigid. Longwear and full-coverage matte concealers are engineered to form a hard, low-transfer film. A hard film on skin that moves every time you blink cracks, and the crack holds pigment.
Cause four: too much setting powder. The standard fix is the fourth cause. Powder in a crease makes the crease read as a pale defined channel, so a heavily set under-eye looks worse than an unset one would have.
Work through those in order and most people solve this without buying anything. If you have, and it still creases, then the formula is the variable left — and the picks below are the ones that behave.
The fold beside the mouth is a different problem from the under-eye crease and mostly wants less concealer rather than a better one, which is covered on best concealer for smile lines.
If the concealer currently creasing on you is a specific cult product rather than a category, alternatives to the NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer is the page for that — it sorts the field by which of the original's properties you are actually trying to keep.