'Always set your concealer' is the most repeated piece of under-eye advice and one of the least suitable for mature skin. It is not wrong in principle — a soft concealer on a mobile area does move, and a little powder holds it — but the amount implied by the advice is several times what this skin tolerates.
The reason is optical. Powder scatters light differently from skin. A fine line with powder sitting in it reads as a defined pale channel rather than a soft crease, so the moment the powder goes on, the line becomes more visible. Then as the day goes on and the product moves slightly, the powder concentrates further into the fold.
So the honest position is a conditional one. Set if your concealer moves, with a trace, and not otherwise. And a surprising number of people find that once they have reduced the amount of concealer and placed it only on the shadow, there is nothing left to set.
This page is a decision rather than an instruction, because the answer genuinely depends on your skin, your formula and how much you used — and the standard advice gives a single answer to a question with several.
If you are weighing powder against a setting spray instead, they are not alternatives: powder absorbs oil where you put it, a spray forms a film over the whole face. Setting spray vs setting powder works through it, and the honest prior question is on do you need setting spray over 50.