Setting spray is the most reliably over-bought product in a makeup bag, and the reason is that it is sold against a feeling rather than against a fault. Nobody describes the specific thing it does; the pitch is that your makeup will last, which sounds universally desirable and tells you nothing about whether you personally need it.
What it physically does is narrow. Polymers in the mist dry into a very thin flexible film over the top of your makeup, and that film holds the makeup where it is. That is the entire mechanism worth paying for. It does not change the base, it does not absorb oil, it does not fill anything, and it has no effect on how the makeup looked before it went on.
So the honest test is whether your problem is movement. Movement means fading, transferring onto a collar or a phone, or shifting position on the face over hours. If that is what happens to you, a spray is the right tool and the only tool. If what happens is something else, a spray will not help and may make it permanent.
And over 50 there is a specific reason the answer skews towards no. The bases that suit mature skin are the thin ones — serum foundations, skin tints, sheer buildable formulas. A thinner base has less product to move in the first place, so it tends to fade gently rather than slide, and gentle fading is not a problem most people want to spend money and an extra step preventing.
There is also a real downside, which the category rarely mentions. Most setting sprays get their hold partly from alcohol evaporating off the surface, and that takes water with it on skin that is already short of both oil and water. A face that feels tight by evening is often wearing the solution to a problem it did not have. The ingredient argument in full, and the formulas that avoid it, are on best setting spray for mature skin.
What to look for if the test below says yes. An alcohol-free formula above everything else; film-forming rather than fast-drying hold; a finish that is not dewy if your T-zone shines; and a mist pump you can press, because a sustained push is harder than a click with sore hands.