Finish is the most consequential choice on a mature face and the least carefully discussed. The choice is usually framed as a style preference — glowy versus polished — when it is actually a question about how light behaves on an uneven surface.
A dewy finish reflects light specularly, meaning it bounces back in a concentrated direction, which is what reads as glow. That works beautifully on a smooth surface. On a surface with dips in it — fine lines, pores, crepiness — each dip catches and returns light from its own angle, which makes the dip visible. This is why a dewy foundation that looked wonderful at 35 can look busy at 65 on exactly the same person.
A flat matte finish scatters light diffusely, which hides texture well in principle. The catch is how matte is achieved: oil absorbers and a harder, more film-forming formula. Both of those emphasize dryness, and a hard film cracks along a crease. So matte solves the texture problem and creates two new ones.
Satin sits between them. Enough light return that skin does not look dead, enough diffusion that texture is not picked out, and no need for the oil absorbers or the rigid film. That is why almost every pick on this site that does not have a specific reason to be elsewhere is satin or demi-matte — the format comparison in serum versus liquid points the same way for the same reasons.
A camera resolves this question differently from a mirror, because a dewy finish records as a bright patch and a matte one records texture — which is why photographs get their own list on best foundation for photos on mature skin.