Being oily at 55 is not a contradiction, it is just underdiscussed. Sebum production falls with age on average, but averages are not people: plenty of mature skin is still oily through the T-zone, and some of it becomes combination — oily in the center, dry at the edges — which is the hardest version to dress.
The problem is that every piece of advice written for oily skin assumes a young face. Longwear matte, oil-free, transfer-proof, powder to set: that regime works on skin with no creases in it. On mature skin it produces a hard film across a face that moves, and the film cracks along the smile lines and the under-eye by mid-afternoon. You have solved the shine and created a worse problem.
What works instead is targeted rather than total. Control oil only where oil happens. Choose a satin finish rather than a flat matte, because satin is achieved with a softer film. Use a grip primer in the center of the face if your foundation slides, and leave the rest bare. And set with the smallest amount of a finely milled powder, in the two or three places that shine — not across the whole face.
If you are oily and also have visible pores, the two go together and the large pores page covers the blurring side of it.
If the oily area is also actively breaking out, the advice shifts again, because acne guidance and mature-skin guidance pull in opposite directions — that conflict is worked through on best foundation for mature acne-prone skin.
If the shine is confined to your nose, forehead and chin while your cheeks feel tight, you have combination skin rather than oily skin, and the right page is best foundation for mature combination skin.
Foundation is one step of a routine that fails as a whole. The sequence matters as much as the formula here, and best makeup for mature oily skin sets out the whole routine in order; if enlarged pores are part of the same complaint, best makeup for mature skin with large pores covers that.
The one format worth a second look if you are oily. A powder foundation covers and absorbs shine in the same pass, which is one layer instead of a liquid plus a setting powder on top — the single-step option is set out on best powder foundation for mature skin.