The standard framing of this question is wrong for this audience. It asks you to identify as oily or dry and buy accordingly, which works on a younger face where the whole surface tends to behave the same way. On mature skin it usually does not: sebum production falls unevenly, so a very common pattern is an oily nose and chin with dry cheeks and a dry area around the mouth and eyes.
Buying a mattifying primer for that face makes three-quarters of it papery to solve one shiny strip. Buying a hydrating primer for it leaves the nose shining by 11am. Both outcomes are the predictable result of treating a face as one surface.
What mattifying primers actually do is absorb oil, using silica, clay or starch powders, and sometimes they add a drying alcohol to accelerate the effect. That is a genuinely useful mechanism where there is oil to absorb. Where there is not, it pulls at the surface and makes texture more visible, because a dry surface scatters light less evenly and every dip reads sharper.
What hydrating primers do is hold water at the surface so your foundation does not dry out from underneath and your skin does not drink it. That is what stops foundation grabbing at dry patches. On an oily area it is one more slippery layer for the foundation to move on.
So the honest advice is to stop choosing and start placing. The oily skin page and the dry skin page both arrive at the same conclusion from opposite directions: treat the areas separately, and pick your foundation for the larger area rather than the shinier one.
When the honest answer is that you need both on the same face, the zoned approach is set out on best foundation for mature combination skin.