Almost every eyeliner frustration over 60 traces back to one thing: the lid folds. As the skin above the eye relaxes, the outer part of the mobile lid tucks under a fold of skin when the eye is open — so anything drawn on that part of the lid is hidden.
The experience is familiar and specific. You close your eye, draw a neat line along the lash line, perhaps a small flick, open your eye — and the line has vanished or become a smudged sliver. The natural response is to draw thicker, which disappears equally and then shows up as a dark smear on the fold when you blink. The eye ends up looking smaller rather than more defined.
Two changes fix it and both are free. Draw with your eyes open, looking straight ahead, so you are working on the part of the lid that is actually visible. And put the line at the lash base rather than above it, because the very root of the lashes is the one place a hood cannot cover — it is below the fold.
That second technique is often called tightlining, and it does a second useful thing on a mature eye: it fills the gaps between sparse lashes, which makes the lash line read denser. On a thinning lash line it does more than mascara does.
A third change is about format, and it is covered properly on best eyeliner for hooded mature eyes: use a firm gel pencil rather than a liquid. A hooded mature lid is neither smooth nor flat, and liquid liner needs both.
The prior question — whether a mature eye should wear liner, and in what style — is answered on should older women wear eyeliner.
Placement matters more than color here, but the color question still has a right answer, and it is on what color eyeliner should an older woman wear.