Smudging that starts in your fifties is almost never a product going bad, and treating it as one leads to replacing mascara repeatedly while the cause stays in place.
It is one of four things, and each has a signature that tells you which is yours.
Cause one: the lower lid sits closer to your lashes. As the skin above the eye relaxes and the lower lid loses a little tone, upper lashes that used to clear the skin now touch it — and anything that touches transfers. This is the most common cause and it is why people describe the smudge appearing in the same place every day.
Cause two: the tear film has changed. Tear production often decreases with age while the eye compensates with reflex watering, so the lower lid area can be intermittently wet in a way it was not before. A wax formula softens against moisture.
Cause three: oil distribution has shifted. Where skin produces oil changes with age, and oil is a solvent for the waxes that hold a conventional mascara together.
Cause four: you are coating your lower lashes. The lower lashes are the ones that touch the lower lid, and a full coat there is the most common self-inflicted cause. Stopping is free.
This page is about transfer through the day. If the mark arrives at the moment of application rather than hours later, that is a lid-shape problem with a different fix — how to apply mascara without getting it on your eyelid.